To Have and Have Not

Audience Reviews

View More

bruce F @bruce999 Aug 3 fun classic movie, has some good acting. not as good as casablanca, or the big sleep, or the maltese falcon, but, it is worth a view. hard to find a movie like this anymore. See more Lorenz L @Lorenz1060 Jul 5 Bogart + Bacall = A sizzling romance for the ages. The charismatic coolness of Hoagy Charmichael almost (but not quite) makes up for Walter Brennan fumbling through the only characterisation he gave in everything in which he appeared for his entire career (same with Dan Seymour). See more Cappy B @Huckleberry42 Feb 8 Bogie and Bacall!! Absolutely fabulous. See more Mickey B. @Mickerdoo Dec 26 Easy to like a reluctant hero in Bogart. Bacall was something (not sure that something was a good singer, though). Eddie is the man. See more Allan C @RT15713161 Aug 24 “Was you ever bit by a dead bee?” To Have and Have Not (1944) ****1/2 Just learned that my wife had never seen a Bogie and Bacall movie, so we had to start at the beginning. From the Hemingway novel, Humphrey Bogart plays an American Expat boat captain who takes a risky job, instead of his usual charter fishing trips, smuggling a French Resistance leader and his wife across heavily patrolled waters. That story is exciting, but what makes the film so memorable is the supporting storylines of Bogie romancing a lounge singer/pickpocket, a young 19-year-old Lauren Bacall, in her film debut, who would end up in real life marrying the 44-year-old Bogart in one of the great Hollywood love stories, staying together until Bogie's death. You can feel the chemistry between them on screen, and it is dynamite! Bacall's "Slim" oozes sex appeal when she tells Bogie's Steve: You know you don't have to act with me, Steve. You don't have to say anything, and you don't have to do anything. Not a thing. Oh, maybe just whistle. You know how to whistle, don't you, Steve? You just put your lips together and... blow.  Adapted by the great American novelist William Faulkner and ace screenwriter Jules Furthman (THE BIG SLEEP, RIO BRAVO, MUTINY ON THE BOUNTY), it's a fantastic screenplay. Pauline Kael once wrote that Furthman "has written about half of the most entertaining movies to come out of Hollywood (Ben Hecht wrote most of the other half)." As with most of his films, director Howard Hawks had a fair amount of uncredited work on the script as well, being a major part in playing up the Bogie and Bacall characters' relationship. There's also a really sweet relationship between Bogie and his rummy friend, the always great Walter Brennan, playing a drunk who annoys everyone he meets by asking them, "Was you ever bit by a dead bee?" The script has a master class moment in character development and succinct dialogue when any annoying tourist on Bogie's boat asks him:  TOURIST: "What d'you look after him for?" BOGIE: "He thinks he's looking after me." That line tells you all you need to know about these two characters, that they've know each other for a long time, that Brennan probably did look after and mentor Bogie as some point in the distant past, and that Bogie, despite his tough exterior, is a loyal and sentimental guy who looks after an old pal who's fallen on hard times, to no benefit of himself. Brilliant! As great as the relationship between these two is, it's all about Bogie and Bacall. Lauren Bacall is truly amazing in her feature film debut. She was never a brilliant actress, but she is the definition of a movie star. You cannot take your eyes off of her, and she manages to steal every scene that she's in, which is saying something with a cast that includes Bogie, Brennan, and even Hoagy Carmichael, who plays her piano accompanist at the shady hotel where everyone is staying. The film may feel a little meandering at times, but that's what I love about old films sometimes. Why not just throw a musical number or two in there that doesn't move the story forward? But for classic film buffs, TO HAVE AND HAVE NOT is a must-see and completely holds up to repeated viewings.  AI CAPSULE REVIEW: To Have and Have Not crackles with the undeniable chemistry of Bogart and Bacall, making it as much a love story as it is a tale of wartime intrigue. Howard Hawks’ direction keeps the pace taut while allowing room for smoky nightclub numbers, witty banter, and Walter Brennan’s unforgettable “dead bee” routine. It may wander at times, but its charm and star power make it an essential classic. See more Kyle M @RT77296778 07/05/2025 Humphrey Bogart’s reliable caliber shows political elusion in an ever-sharp deliverance, bolstering this non-engaging bland parallel to “Casablanca” with an adjacent deck, further advocating Ernest Hemingway’s thought regarding the source material being his worst. (B) See more Read all reviews

To Have and Have Not

My Rating

Read More Read Less WRITE A REVIEW EDIT REVIEW POST RATING